Case commentary · Independent analysis · 19 November 2026

Kadrey v. Meta Platforms: A.I. Training and Market Harm to Authors

In AI Copyright Cases, Market Evidence Decides

A case commentary on why market harm, not transformation, sat at the centre of the Northern District of California’s ruling on Meta’s Llama training.

Educational purposes only, not legal advice. Independent commentary by a non-attorney; not filed with any court. Read the court's original opinion for the authoritative text.

Case: Kadrey v. Meta Platforms, Inc., No. 3:23-cv-03417-VC, Order on Cross-Motions for Partial Summary Judgment, slip op. (N.D. Cal. June 25, 2025) (Chhabria, J.)

fair usemarket harmmarket dilutionAI trainingauthors

Meta won on fair use against thirteen authors whose books were used to train its Llama models. But the court stressed that the ruling turned on the authors’ failure to present evidence, identified market dilution as a "potentially winning argument", and said the decision does not stand for the proposition that the use was lawful. The commentary explains why.

What you will take from it

  • Understand how the court weighed the four fair use factors on this record, and why the fourth factor decided the case.
  • See the three theories of market harm the court considered: regurgitation, a lost licensing market and market dilution.
  • Compare the court’s approach with *Bartz v. Anthropic*, decided two days earlier in the same court.
  • Follow the verified later history, including the DMCA ruling, the March 2026 amendment order and an October 2026 discovery order.
  • Take general observations for authors and rights holders on the role of market evidence.

For authors and for organisations that hold rights in written works, the most practical lesson of *Kadrey* is that the strength of a challenge to AI training may depend on evidence of how AI outputs actually affect demand for the original works.

From the Open Questions, *Kadrey v. Meta Platforms* case commentary.

Background

Meta won on fair use against thirteen authors whose books were used to train its Llama models. But the court stressed that the ruling turned on the authors’ failure to present evidence, identified market dilution as a "potentially winning argument", and said the decision does not stand for the proposition that the use was lawful. The commentary explains why.

Understand how the court weighed the four fair use factors on this record, and why the fourth factor decided the case. See the three theories of market harm the court considered: regurgitation, a lost licensing market and market dilution. Compare the court’s approach with *Bartz v. Anthropic*, decided two days earlier in the same court.

Follow the verified later history, including the DMCA ruling, the March 2026 amendment order and an October 2026 discovery order. Take general observations for authors and rights holders on the role of market evidence.

Frequently asked questions

Did the court say training AI on books is legal?
No. It granted Meta partial summary judgment on this record, but expressly said the ruling does not stand for the proposition that using copyrighted materials to train language models is lawful.
What is market dilution?
The theory that a model trained on books can generate large numbers of similar works that compete with the originals. The court called it the "potentially winning argument" but found the authors had presented no meaningful evidence on it.
Is this legal advice?
No. It is independent commentary by a non-attorney for educational purposes, not advice about any particular use of data.

Source

More from Thomas Guerriero

See all research at Research, and the main hub at ThomasGuerriero.com. Also: ThomasAGuerrieroPhD.com · ThomasAGuerriero.com.

For educational purposes only; not legal advice. This page summarises independent commentary on a public court opinion and links to the original. A PDF of the commentary is available on this page.

Pursue greatness

Don't get left behind. Chase greatness.

If you want help growing your business, team, or just want to pursue greatness yourself, book a free 15 minute call at the link below.

cal.com/thomas-guerriero-gvx0zs/15min